• 20.09.2018 Administrator UMB

    On Plica Polonica and the forgotten Joseph Romain Louis Kerckhoffs (1789- 1867)

    Ohry A.1*, Ohana N.2

     

     

    1. Emeritus Professor of Rehabilitation Medicine, Reuth Medical & Rehabilitation Center,            Tel Aviv, and Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, Israel
    2. Dermatologist, retired Director General of Reuth Medical & Rehabilitation Hospital,                   Tel Aviv, Israel

     

     

    _____________________________________________________________________________

    A- Conception and study design; B - Collection of data; C - Data analysis; D - Writing the paper;

    E- Review article; F - Approval of the final version of the article; G - Other (please specify)

    _____________________________________________________________________________________________

     

    ABSTRACT

    _____________________________________________________________________________________________

                       

     

                        Plica Polonica (or Plica Neuropathica)                   is a rare hair disorder, an acute hair felting. The one who described this phenomenon thoroughly and                  who has been almost totally absent in history-of-medicine textbooks, is  the French - Dutch physician,

     

    Joseph Romain Louis  Kerckhoffs (or Kerckhove) (1789 - 1867).

    Keywords: Plica Polonica, Joseph Romain Louis  Kerckhoffs

     

     

    ____________________________________________________________________________________

     

    DOI: 10.5604/01.3001.0012.1331

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    *Corresponding author:

    Avi Ohry,

    Emeritus Professor of Rehabilitation Medicine

    Reuth Medical & Rehabilitation Center, Tel Aviv, and Sackler Faculty of Medicine

    Tel Aviv University, Israel,

    email: aohry@post.tau.ac.il

     

     

     

    Received: 08.01.2018

    Accepted: 16.02.2018

    Progress in Health Sciences

    Vol. 8(1) 2018  208-212

    © Medical University of Białystok, Poland

     

    Blanket my loins: elf all my hair in knots

    (W. Shakespeare’s “King Lear,”

    Edgar in Act II, Scene III)

     

    INTRODUCTION

     

    Medical eponyms are usually named after physicians, scientists, causative agents, saints, and rarely after "famous" patients [1].

     Occasionally, one can encounter with a (recent or archaic term) disease or syndrome which were coined after a city, country, river, an area, or an island: "the French disease", "the Italian disease", Guinea Worm, West Nile Virus, German Measles, Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever, Marburg Virus Disease, St. Louis Encephalitis, Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever, Lyme Disease, Meleda disease and more. Less known is a dermatologic term: "Plica Polonica". This rare phenomenon is mentioned today only 19 times on PubMed site.

     

    The Dermatological Problem

              Plica Polonica (or plica neuropathica) is a rare hair-disorder, an acute hair felting, which is associated with lice eggs on hair, chemotherapy, azathioprine-induced pancytopenia, seborrheic dermatitis, schizophrenia, after use of shampoo, rupoid psoriasis, trichoma, pediculosis capitis and scabies. It is "characterized by irreversible twisting and matting ofhair resultinginahardimpermeablemassofkeratin...ithasbeenattributetolongitudinalsplitting or weathering of hair shaft due to vigorous friction and frequent use of harsh shampoos and harsh cleansers and/or due to keeping long hair with poor hair care or neglect, parasitic infection" [2].

     "Acute hair felting is a rare disorder of scalp hair. In this condition, the hair becomestwisted,entangledasahardstonymassresemblingabird'snest.Suddenhairmatting hasbeenreportedearlierintheliteratureaftervigoroususeofchemicalandherbalshampoos. Plica polonica is a patchy area of hair matting occurring in due course of time in neglected hair or underlying psychiatric illness"[3].

         The basic textbook on history of medicine [4] says: "plica polonica, the unsightly disease of matted hair, introduced into Poland by the Mongol invasion, 1287".

     

    Le Page and Kerckhoffs

    A physician from Manchester, JF Le Page, coined the term plica neuropathica in 1884 but he did not mention the one who described thoroughly the phenomenon and who is almost totally absent in history of medicine textbooks: the French-Dutch physician, JosephRomain Louis Kerckhoffs (or Kerckhove) (1789- 1867) [5].

    He was the only son of Marie-Gertrude Lindge–Kerckhoffs (1767-1841), and Jean-François Kerckhoffs (1748-1819). His fatherwas asurgeonandamayorofNuth,Holland,andgavehissonanhomeeducationbyaJesuitMonk. By his father suggestion, he left to Heidelberg and Strasbourg to study law. But he chose medicine. He got his MD degree in 1811. His dissertation was on: "l’air atmospherique etson influence sur léconomie animale". In 1814 he got married to Grégorine-Anne-Marie Chapuis in Maestricht [5-6].

    The "Larousse Dictionnaire historique des Me'decins" described him as follows[7]:               "JosephKerchoveVanderVarent,chirurgienmillitairebelge(Nuth1789-Malines1867). Chirurgien de l'arme'e napoleonienne en Russie, en Allemagne et en France, il sert ensuite les Pays-Bas et devient me'decine-chef du service de sante' militaire d'Anvers . Son fils Euge'ne fut un politicien connu ".

                  In 1833, he changed his name to "De Kerckhove"[8].

     

                   Joseph Kerckhoffs [9]

     

    As a military surgeon, ("ancien médecin en chef des hôpitaux militaires, commandeur et chevalier de plusieurs Ordres de mérite, commandeur de l'Ordre noble du phénix de Hohenlohe, chevalier de l'Ordre du Saint-Sépulcre de Jérusalem, etc,"), he served the Napoleonic French Army between 1812-15, when Holland was annexed to France. After 1815 he was in charge of the military hospitals in Holland.

    He published books on public health and fought against charlatanism. In 1842 he founded the " Academie d’Archeologie de Belgique" . His last days were spent with his son Eugène de Kerckhove, the mayor of Mechelen, and died at 78 years of age. It is interestingto note, that although he served the French army in high medical positions (under Marshal oftheEmpire Michel Ney and Victor van Bellune, Claude Victor-Perrin, First Duc de Belluno), the Prussions invited him after Napoleon fall, to serve as the chief medical officer of their army! But he chose to return to a much lower positions, in the Low Countries (Holland and Belgium were united from 1815 to 1830). He worked in Lie'ge and Antwerpen until he retired in 1823. After his military service he devoted himself to help the poor, and fought against King Willem the1stordertoclosedownhospitalsbecauseofeconomicreasons.PrinceFrederickaskedhim to consult "welfare-villages " and to fight against contagious diseases. He wrote his epidemiological experience n his “Memoires de Cholera”[8].

    On a genealogical site [10], he appears as: Josephus Kerckhoffs, Comte du Royaume des deux Siciles 1789-1867, Ancestry Chart, Descendancy Chart.

     

     

     

     

    Jean François

    Kerckhoffs

     

    1748-1819

     

    Marie Gertrude Lindgens 1767-1841

     

    Alexandre Joseph Chapuis 1763-1837

     

    Marie Hélène Bours 1751-1831

     

    Pierre de Peñaranda, Seigneur de Franchimont 1764-1823

     

     

    Thérèse Wynckelman 1772-1825

     

     

    | 8

     

    | 9

     

    | 10

     

    | 11

     

    | 12

     

    | 13

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    |

     

    |

     

    |

     

     

    Josephus Kerckhoffs, Comte du Royaume des deux Siciles

    1789-1867

     

    Anne-Marie Chapuis 1794-1884

     

    Désiré de Peñaranda de Franchimont 1799-1863

     

    Rosamonde

    Spong

    1797-1872

    | 4

     

    | 5

     

    | 6

     

    | 7

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    |

     

    |

    Antoine de Kerckhove,

    Vicomte de Kerckhove 1817-1889

     

    Marie de Peñaranda de Franchimont

    1832-1912

    | 2

     

    | 3

     

     

     

    |

    Louis de Kerckhove dit van der Varent

    1879-1958

     

     

     

    Dr. J. R. L. Kerckhove had published many books [11,12]: among them - "Observations médicales faites pendant les Campagnes de Russie en 1812 et d'Allemagne 1813" [12]; "Hygiène militaire, ou, Avis sur les moyens de conserver la santé des troupes :ouvrage pour le service de terre" 1815-23; " Histoire des maladies observées à la Grande Arméefrançaise,pendantlescampagnesdeRussieen1812etd'Allemagneen1813";"Hygiènemilitaire,àl'usagedesarméesdeterre1823;"Considérationssurlanatureetletraitementdu choléra-morbus, suivies d'une instruction sur les préceptes hygiéniques contre cette maladie"; " Considérations pratiques sur les fièvres intermittentes, avec des avis sur les moyens de

     

    s'en préserver dans les localités humides et marécageuses 1825"; Notes d'un voyage fait en Espagne"; "Statuts De L'ordre Chapitral D'ancienne Noblesse Des Quatre Empereurs D'allemagne Langue Germanique Ou Primitive"[12,13].

    Inoneofhisbooks[13],hehaddescribedtheplicapolonica.

    SirDominicJohnCorrigan (1802–1880), was an Irish physician, who described the abnormal "collapsing" pulse of aortic valve insufficiency – the Corrigan's pulse, in The Cyclopedia of Practical Medicine, he gave a full –lengthy description of the plica polonica phenomenon [14]: "Plica Polonica, from plico, to knit together. This disease derives its name from the manner in which the hair is plaited or matted together is of most frequent occurrence in Poland…in Tartary, among Cossacks of Russia, in Hungary and in a few instances in Switzerland and France. Schlegel, a physician practicing in Moscow, who published a work on plica in 1806, gives a singular account of its origin. the prejudice in favour of plica is extended even to inferior animals…the physicians of Poland have not escaped the contagion of the prejudice. Kerckhoff whose observations were madeduringthestayoftheFrencharmyinPoland,relatedacaseillustrativeofthis.…”[14].

    Corrigan actually reviewed the literature. He mentioned other physicians andsurgeons, who examined "patients" with the plica: Napoleon's chief surgeon - J.D. Larrey, Lafontaine Robin (surgeon to Frederick the Great), Francois Pierre Chaumeton, Mouton and more. He cited a Scottish physician, William Davisson (1593-1669) "the physician to the Polish king John Casimir and the queen Marie Louise, wrote that plica polonica was due solely to uncleanliness and lack of care of hair" [1668], that he treated successfully 10000 patientswith plica!? [15].

    Baron Larrey added that sometimes patients with plica, complained about bone and joints' pain. "Schlegel (1806) reviewed the literature (on plica polonica) of the previous 200 years and listed 136 papers, dissertations and monographs from different authors… Schlegel wrote that trichoma had a lethality of 5%, leaving 45% of the affected crippled and with 50% makingafullrecovery.Hefeltthattrichomawasthetruecauseofupto32000of55000deaths per year. The estimated prevalence was 1:10 to 1: 30 ”[16].

    F.L. de La Fontaine, Counsellor and Surgeon to the King, wrote: “Plica Polonica, a disease endemic in Poland, and its neighboring countries, in which morbid matter is critically depositeduponthehair,andbindsittogetherinsuchamanner,thattounravelitisimpossible. Experience shows, that it is contagious, and very often congenital. There is no certainty where it first arose; the Arabians, Greeks and Romans, do not mention it; but some modern (19th Century) writers make the date of its origin, 1387, and add, that it came from Tartary” (in 1808)[17,18].

    Many kinds of treatments were suggested: shaving (presumably, when the etiology of plica was "dirt"), partial cutting of hair and "eliminating virus trichomaticus"! we have noidea what was really suggested in this last "method" [18].

    An ancient explanation for the plica phenomenon was put [15]: "Most authors ascribe it to uncleanliness, which is no doubt the ordinary exciting cause, though there seem to be others of equal efficiency. It is also very generally affirmed to be contagious; and i had hence added this character to the disease inthe volume of Nosology. But as Dr. Kerckhoffs strenuously maintains the contrary, after a very minute attention to the complaint in Poland itself, and more especially after having in vain endeavoured to inoculate first himself, and then two children, from the matter issuing fromthe bulbsofhairpulledforthispurposefromaboywhowassufferingfromitinthemostloathsome manner, I have here withdrawn the symptom. Dr. Kerckhoffs reduces plica to a much simpler principlethanithashithertobeendescribedunder,andstripsitofmanyofthemostformidable featuresbywhichithasbeencharacterized;particularlyitsconnexionwithhecticfever,orany idiopathicaffectionofthebrain…Heregardsitasamereresultofthecustomcommonamong the lowest classes of the Polonese, of letting the hair grow to an immense length,” of never combing, or in any other way cleaning it, and of constantly covering the head with a thick woollen bonnet or leathern cap. …Admitting Dr. Kerckhoffs' explanation of this disease to be correct,itissomewhatsingular,thatthesameexplanationhasneverhithertobeengivenbythe most intelligent and most celebrated Polish or even German physicians…. Hence Sinapius (Jakub Hořčický <Jacobus Sinapius> (1575 – 1622), was a Bohemian pharmacist andpersonal doctor of Emperor Rudolf II. and numerous other writers, deny uncleanliness to be the only, or even the ordinary cause. P.R Vicat recommends the use of the scissors whenever the hairs bleed (1775).

     It is far better, with Dr. Kerckhoffs, to use them beforehand…“. Though the disease has been usually confined to the hair of the scalp, it has occasionally appeared in other quarters,asinthebeard,thearmpits,andeventhepudendum:authoritiesforwhicharequoted in the volume of Nosology. From the great afflux of fluids, and even of blood, to the head, during this disease, it

     

    is often accompanied with hemicrania, or some other cephalalgic affection...".

    The rare condition of Plica Polonica is still mentioned in the medical literature. Although many physicians and authors had described it with some possible etiological  considerations and probable treatments . it was a forgotten French-Dutch military physician who left us with the most comprehensive account of the disease: Joseph Romain Louis Kerckhoffs.

     

    REFERENCES

     

    1. Ohry A. The forgotten stories on patients who made history. Prog Health Sci 2013 Jun; 3(1):134-41.
    2. GuptaS,KumarR,VijayA,JainSK.PlicaPolonicainaPatientonChemotherapy:ACase Report with Review of Literature. Int J Trichology 2017Jul-Sep;9(3):124-6.
    3. Maduri VR, Vedachalam A, Kiruthika S. Castor Oil - The Culprit of Acute Hair Felting. Int J Trichology. 2017Jul-Sep;9(3):116-8.
    4. Garrison FH An introduction to the History of Medicine. 4th edition, WB Saundres, Philadelphia & London, 1929.187p.
    5. Le Page JF. On Neuropathic Plica. Br Med J 1884 Jan26;1(1204):160.
    6. Kerckhove JRL. de, Histoire des maladies observées à la grande armée française, pendant les campagnes de Russie en 1812 et d'Allemagne en 1813 [Texte imprimé] / - 3eédition. Anvers: impr. T.-J. Janssens, Maestricht, Holland,1814, & 1836.
    7. Dupont M. The Larousse Dictionnaire historique des Me'decins Collection: Gds Dictionnair; Langue: Français.1999.
    8. Kirckhoff,           Joseph       Romain       Louis      

          de (1789-1867) [Internet]Available       from: https://www.bestor.be/wiki/index.php/Kirckhoff,_Joseph_Romain_Louis_de_(1789-1867) [cited 2018 Feb9].

    1. Joseph Kerckhoffs [Internet] Available from: https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jose ph_  Kerckhoffs [cited 2018 Feb9].
    2. Louis De Kerckhove Dit Van Der Varent [Internet] Available from: https://gw. ge-neanet.org/pierfit?lang=en&p=louis&n=de+kerckhove+dit+van+der+varent [cited2018 Feb9].
    3. van der Heyden NJ Extrait du Nobiliaire de Belgique, concernment kerckhove-Varent et contenant la biographie dy Vicomte Joseph Romain Louis de Kerckhove-Varent, French Edition,2012.
    4. DeBorchatPEMe'moirehistoriqueetge'ne'alogiquesurlatre'sanciennenoblemaisonde Kerchove.TJJanssens.Anvers,1839[in:]BulletinetAnnalesl'Academied'Archeologique de Belgique, tom 1er, Froment. Anvers, 1843;79-84.
    5. Kerckhove-varent L, Observations médicales : faites pendant les Campagnes de Russie en 1812 et d'Allemagne 1813. L. Th. Nypels, aîné, Maestricht1814.
    6. Dunglison R 1798-1869; Forbes J 1787-1861; Tweedie A 1794-1884; Conolly J 1794- 1866, The cyclopaedia of practical medicine: comprising treatises on the nature and treatment of diseases, materia medica and therapeutics, medical jurisprudence, etc. Vol 4: Lea and Blanchard, Philadelphia, 1845.
    7. A Brief History of Plica Polonica [Internet] Available from: http://nuvo-forheadlice. com/ Plica.htm [cited 2018 Feb9].
    8. Schlegel JFA. Über die Ursachen des Weichselzopfes der Menschen und Thiere. Jena:J. Göpferdt C.G. 1806.
    9. De La Fontaine FL Traite de la Plique Polonaise, etc., Paris 1808 excerpt translated inDe La Fontaine on Plica Polonica in J.R. Cox, The Philadelphia Medical Museum, IV: x-xii, Thomas Dobson,Philadelphia,1808.
    10. Mason Good J, Cooper S. The Study of Medicine, Vol. 2, NYC, Harper & Brothers, 1835, p. 695.